Early Review: Starship Soldiers Vs. Starship Troopers
I’ve been reading the novel ‘Starship Soldiers’ or what it is known as by many, ‘Starship Troopers’ written by Robert Heinlein. The futuristic novel published in 1959 follows the life of Juan Rico in views of flash backs after he graduates from high school and enlists in the Terran Mobile Infantry.
I have only read up to Chapter VIII (Chapter 8 ) so far and it is much, much, more different than the movie, ‘Starship Troopers’ which was released in 1997 starring Denise Richards, Neil Patrick Harris, and Casper Van Dien. First off, this book explores the deep and unknown reality that war veterans face after a war and how the government screws them over. The book even explores political themes and how politics always affects everyone and everything. I am not at the part yet where they start fighting the war with the bugs but from what I have been reading so far, it does not even seem like they will be fighting bugs, just super tall and skinny humanoid beings. The movie is all about action and explosions. Everyone has a gun and is shooting at a bug. Blood, guts, gore, napalm, body parts, and bugs. That is pretty much what the movie is about.
The major differences that occur between the movie and the book are the major scenes that you see in the movie. Most of the memorable scenes from the movie always end up in someone being killed or injured. The first discrepancy between the book and the movie is that ‘Dizzy’ is not female but he is male and dies in the first chapter due to mortal wounds, not due to an insect leg impaling her through the chest. There are also the MI capsules that all the soldiers are launched out of. In the movie, all the soldiers are carried down to the planet in supply ships but in the book, every soldier is launched out of the base ship from orbit while in a capsule waiting to crash land onto the planet to start fighting.
What I find very interesting about the scenes that Heinlein wrote about is whenever there is a conflict of man vs. man he writes at least two pages of political and philosophical ideals that represent the situation and also as well diffuses and gives each problem closure.
Very memorable scenes in the book are the same memorable scenes in the movie but instead of shooting, there is a major explanation diffusing the situation. The scene where ‘Ace’ complains to drill instructor Zim that why they need knives, Heinlein explains philosophically in three pages why one man should be skilled in knives and why one should have one. It does not even end up with Zim throwing the knife at Ace’s hand like in the movie. Another scene where Zim breaks the arm of a recruit, Heinlin writes a logical and political description of the rules of fighting and in which ways to fight someone. The biggest scene so far in the book is when a soldier disobeys Zim’s orders and actually hits the drill instructor which by law is punished by flogging and also being relieved of his duties. The entire chapter deals with how and why to never hit your superior and why the superior, Zim let his guard down and let the recruit sock him in the eye. This scene leads to Rico’s flogging which many remember that he got one of his subordinates killed by taking off his helmet. In the novel, the Mobile Infantry uses power suits which basically turns the human operator into a super freak. Rico was in charge of his company in a drill and he shoots a missile to prevent the attackers from killing his teammates. Unfortunately, he did not really think about his decision and could have actually possibly killed his own teammates and he was given five lashes due to negligence.
If you ever get to read this book and expect a plethora of explosions and insect body parts flying all over the place, think again. This novel was nothing like I expected it to be, which makes me very disappointed in how the movie turned out. The movie barely explored the themes presented in the book written by Heinlein and if you are not into philosophy and politics, this book will have you asking yourself, ‘what the hell did I just read?’ It can get so boring that you will forget what you just read. The movie, ‘Starship Troopers’ is nothing like the novel, ‘Starship Soldiers’ so if you are one of the fans who loved the movie, you probably will not like the book and find it too boring to read.
I on the other hand am actually going to mission this novel out and hope that they actually do fight some bugs!